
Introduction to Diagnostic Testing
Synopsis: An activity which introduces diagnostic testing.
Students work with at least one other student to analyze data in an attempt
to determine the accuracy of a pregnancy test.
Type of activity: In-class, small-group
Statistical topics: diagnostic testing, conditional probabilities
Time needed: 10 minutes
Materials needed:
-
An activity form (HTML
Version)
-
A home pregnancy kit (not necessary, but helpful in introducing the activity)
Procedure:
Part I
-
Introduce the activity by reading the reported accuracy of the home pregnancy
test.
-
Ask students to work with at least one other student.
-
Give one activity form to each student.
-
Ask students to study the two-way table and analyze the data.
-
Ask the students to answer the questions on the activity form to determine
the accuracy of a pregnancy test.
Part II
After the students have completed the activity, the class should come
back together as a group to discuss the purpose of the activity. The instructor
can initiate the discussion by asking the students what they learned in
doing this activity. Points to include:
-
the accuracy of a diagnostic test during development is not necessarily
the accuracy of a diagnostic test in use
-
P(A|B) does not necessarily equal P(B|A)
-
low prevalence of disease contributes to high false positive rates.
-
screening tests generally have high negative predictive values but low
positive predictive values.
Comments from others who have tried activity: None.
Supplementary materials: Activity Form: HTML
Version
This activity was submitted by Laura J. Simon: lsimon@stat.psu.edu